Sanjiv Handa, Oakland government gadfly and transparency advocate, dead at 55

Sanjiv Handa by Ken Katz, used with permission

Sanjiv Handa by Ken Katz, used with permission

Police have confirmed that Sanjiv Handa, publisher and editor of the East Bay News Service, an email newsletter Handa sent out to a protected list of influencers and subscribers, was found dead on Tuesday morning.  Rumored to have been ill, Handa attended the last Oakland City Council meeting before the winter recess and spoke on local issues as usual. 

Oakland politicians, change-makers and city government observers both cursed and admired Handa for his unrelenting, obsessive attention to detail when it came to the city's observance of the Sunshine Laws and of government transparency in general. 

Handa was one of the first, for example, to write that Jakada Imani's appointment as a port commissioner in Fall 2011 may not have been legal due to a failure to follow required processes; he was proven to be correct.  And yet, the same time that Handa was admired for his throughness and knowledge of civic law, he was often a figure of fun; bloggers and others made fun of his fondess for baked goods, which he often brought with him to meetings and events, his slow, ponderous style of speech, and his tunnel-vision when it came to exposing weaknesses and flaws in the due processes of city government.

We've pulled together a Storify that reflects both some of the local coverage of Handa as a personality and the voices in the Twittersphere commenting on his loss. OL is sorry for his loss.


About Susan Mernit

Susan Mernit is the founder of Oakland Local. She is also a circuit rider for The Community Information Challenge, a program of The John S and James L Knight Foundation, and a consultant to non-profit and community organizations. Susan lives in North Oakland, near the Santa Fe school, with her partner, her housemate, a rescue dog named Cazzie, and a yard full of ants. She is an aspiring gardener, a long-time blogger & entrepreneur, and a recovering journalist who's found home in Oakland.

I sat next to Sanjiv last Monday night. He said he was sick and encouraged me not to get too close, so I thought it was a flu or a cold. He was using a cane, though, and he spoke from his seat, using a wireless mic, instead of walking to the podium.  I was somewhat concerned about his health, but never dreamed it was this precarious.

What a loss! I wonder if there's a "Son of Sanjiv" somewhere in our community who will carry on the good fight for integrity and transparency in government.

Sanjiv had a generous soul; he made a point of going to Starbucks and Noah's at closing time, grabbing the unsold bagels and patries, and giving them to the needy.

I can't imagine City Council meetings without him! May he find his reward.

This is a true loss.  Sanjiv was such a nice and gental man.  He always took the time to listen and to help everyone.  He was so great to my 5 year old.  He used to let him take pictures of City Council with his fancy Nikon.  WE WILL ALL MISS YOU, OUR DEAR DEAR FRIEND.  The hearts of us Oaklanders go with you and your love is safe with us. 

Yes, my gut instinct is telling me that Handa was assassinated. There are many subtle ways to do something like that. He's a probable target for the obvious reasons of even just, even usually accurately, verbally attacking power in fascist times. He's a practical target because he's older, has a stressful role (even if self chosen) sits a lot and is quite overweight. Californians, unlike New Yorkers and people from much of the rest of the country, are very ageist and expect an overweight guy like him to just up and die. Here in California, another thought in the collective mind questioning why he would now die, will not occur. Plenty of plausible deniability for assassinating entities exists as cover for anyone who would do something like that to Mr. Handa. He definitely provided a motive with his pointed, sometimes verging on personal but never baselessly ad hominem, attacks on people not used to being questioned after 30 years of Reaganomics. He had lots of enemies who work very hard to maintain the Reaganomics status quo of sticking it to working people (budgetary poor mouthing), all the while never increasing taxes on the richest individuals or corporations (parasites). I know of absolutely no one who put their money where their mouth is more than Sanjeev did in any form of activism. He could have just had a heart attack, stroke, aneurism, whatever, which, of course, could be the case. But, was there anything to help such an outcome along? Handa, though he had a small hooptie auto, walked miles on many days of the week, which leads me to believe that he was not a candidate for sudden onset heart disease though he may have suffered from high blood pressure that politics, especially the modern disappointing nature of politics at nearly every level, will exacerbate. Also, Handa, very poor without adequate access to services as far as we all know, is actually expressing a longevity that is normal for the poor and stressed out increasingly in the U.S. Stress of poverty kills and also causes Type II diabetes. Did he have this? If he did, it's very easy to die from missing an injection or pill and one could die in one's sleep. Yes, there is lots of plausible deniability if anyone did assassinate him by any number of subtle means. When full martial law finally fully lowers gloweringly over us all, anyone who is like him will be summarily executed--just taken somewhere remote and shot. Friends in Tunisia and my professor in Egypt told me that this was often the outcome, along with lengthy political imprisonments and torture, for any outspoken individual who was even mildly but publically critical of the regimes in place--a stray comment could result in assassination, under Mubarak and before the Arab Spring in Tunisia. Damned interesting stuff. Who’s going to help hold back the fascism now in Oakland? I will definitely miss Mr. Handa very much. His faults with blemishes and all were absolutely irrelevant proportionate to the good he did daily. He wasn't just an interesting character (enough for me to miss someone when they're gone), but a valuable member of the community committed every day to making things better. His energies were directed against those most responsible. In fact, he did not lie or exaggerate. The criminal at the top of any extant hierarchy, are by the nature of said hierarchies all execrable prevaricating criminals. The system is broken and needs full overhaul to create directly democratic government structures, fully responsive to the public with full transparency that Handa is correct, we utterly lack in Oakland. Handa rocked whilst he lived! I'm certain that City Council meetings will be far less eventful and the blood pressure of the criminals who make up the City Council, whomever they are under this actually non-representative Republic-based system, will grow regressively and in a cancerously criminal way without having Mr. Handa or anyone like him to hold filthy business-first politicos feet to the flame. My approach to criticizing power (truth to power) in person is much more thuggish. I would like to learn to be more subtle, and he was subtle in being so specific and concise in his criticisms. He was a miracle of a person. He was able to keep up with all the ballooning interlacing layers of distortion inevitably produced by a predatory, non-representative, exploitative leadership support system, inevitably. He, where are the rest of us, kept up with a pile of figurative excrement so filthy, so complex, old, and stale that it would drive most of us to drink first. Again, I will truly miss this great thought warrior, Mr. Handa. You have honored Athena and the Goddess in General. May your future lives be rewarding.


 
Frank

 
P.S: I could fathom being wrong if Sanjeev was eating a lot of radionuclide contaminated food (tap water, tuna, seafood like sushi, milk, cheese, potatoes and other root crops--it should be assumed that at least these products are very strongly contaminated with radionuclides and this contamination will worsen because Fukushima has not stopped emitting radionuclides for 9 months and going strong, as Chernobyl did stop after only one week for comparison. If he was ingesting a lot of those things and had a precondition of Type II diabetes, heart disease of whatever kind, poor eliminatory systems--i.e., Chrons, then, previous studies from Chernobyl show that one could die suddenly and out of the blue from a sudden heart stoppage without fowl play. See the documentary (short and easily found online) "Chernobyl Heart" (please pass along to Marie)  Epidemic heart disease and cancer rates post Chernobyl in Ukraine, Russia and Belarus, all formerly, U.S.S.R. were predicted, expected and are occurring, 25 years after the last fissioning of the now glassified corium from the Chernobyl Nuclear Accident. FS

Sanjeev was not a "gadfly"; he was a warrior, a dragon. Neither was he a "mukraker". Mukraking is a behavior of slinging figurative mud about personal, not political backgrounds,, valid or not, by politicians during political campaigns. English is a flexible language with exceptional and flexible figurative uses; but, Sanjiv was not a politician, he was politically aware and politically active as a citizen. He was that preciously and bizarrely rare gemlike journalist these days, the journalist who tells the truth whatever the consequences. Telling the truth is not muckraking. Communicating the truth and working hard to cover big pictures is not being a "gadfly". To whomever is writing about Mr. Handa or opining about Mr. Handa, if you, the writer does not have the big-picture reality evaluation skills of Mr. Handa, this is not a reason to minimize the value of an individual like Mr. Handa. He is what our founding fathers should have been like, but they were not like Mr. Handa. Founding "fathers" in our filthy martial non-representative patriarchy were slave holding equivalents of moder parasitic billionaires. He, to contrast, is the face that informs all change that benefits we non-billionaires. May similarly irritating individuals rise...and they will.

I just returned from Sanjiv's funeral. I was happy that there were hundreds of people there -- in fact, it was standing room only. This was appropriate for the man who worked tirelessly to keep Oakland's often-disfunctional goverment aware that it was being watched. His impact on the city was demonstrated by the number and position of those who mourn him.

Sanjiv fearlessly spoke truth to power, and relentlessly campigned for open and honest governnment. He was often a pain in the butt to those in authority, and was not bothered by being considered a pest by those who most needed his attention. He was a walking history book of the workings of Oakland for the past twenty years. His commments often raised important issues that others would have preferred not to address. He made Oakland a better place.

He was also friendly and kind, and often brought and shared food at the intermidable meetings at which he was a fixture. At his funeral, several people mentioned how much he loved children, and he was, in his own way, childish in his insistence on honesty and following the rules, and intolerance for hipocracy or shady dealings.

So let me repeat the signature phrase which we who heard hundreds of times, with varying degrees of appreciation, knew always preceeded his insightful comments. I imagine him announcing at the Pearly Gates, "For the record, I am Sanjiv Handa, East Bay News Service." 

Rest in peace, Sanjiv. 

Ben, thank you for sharing your account. Love this: I imagine him announcing at the Pearly Gates, "For the record, I am Sanjiv Handa, East Bay News Service."